Pareto Equilibrium and Optimal Loss Function for Monetary and Fiscal Policymakers in a Cooperative Game, Considering Government Uncertainty in Achieving Budget Revenue

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 1. Department of Economics, Faculty of Administrative Sciences and Economics, Vali-e-Asr University of Rafsanjan, Rafsanjan, Iran.

2 Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Mathematics, Vali-e-Asr University of Rafsanjan, Rafsanjan, Iran.

Abstract

Macroeconomic policies highlight the importance of coordination between the government and the central bank in ensuring the effective attainment of their desired goals. Economic literature shows that cooperation between these key players and policymakers can yield improved outcomes concerning economic growth and stable inflation in contrast to situations where they act independently. A crucial challenge these players may face in this game is the uncertainty surrounding the fiscal authority's capacity to secure its intended budgetary targets, prompting the policymakers to exercise more caution when responding to policy measures. The present study, therefore, aims to analyze the best response function, Pareto equilibrium, and loss function of the government and the central bank in cooperative games. The findings indicate that within a cooperative framework, the monetary authority's response function exhibits contradictory tendencies due to increased policy interest rates, as demonstrated by the simulation results in the game. Additionally, within a cooperative scenario, the Pareto equilibrium is established at a lower level than the Nash equilibrium considering inflation stability and economic growth. Furthermore, within the cooperative context, the government undergoes a lower loss function and budget deficit, while the central bank experiences a higher loss function in the non-cooperative game. However, with a decrease in the economic uncertainty level, the equilibrium output level increases in cooperative and non-cooperative scenarios. Ultimately, the current study offers a set of policy recommendations based on the findings.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

توکلیان، حسین، طاهرپور، جواد، و محسن­پور، فرزاد. (1398). هماهنگی و اثر متقابل سیاست­های مالی و پولی در اقتصاد ایران: یک الگوی تعادل عمومی پویای تصادفی. فصلنامه پژوهش و سیاستهای اقتصادی، 27(90)، 195–241.
محتشمی، مینا، احسانی، محمدعلی، و فیضی، مهدی. (1399). تحلیل رفاهی تعامل بین دولت و بانک مرکزی در چارچوب بازی‌های سیاستی. فصلنامه اقتصاد و الگوسازی، 11(3)، 1-31.
محمودی نیا، داود، و زیدآبادی، اطهره. (1399). بررسی تعامل رفتار دولت و بانک مرکزی در یک بازی رهبر-پیرو با وجود صرف ریسک (کاربردی از بازی دیفرانسیلی غیر خطی). فصلنامه اقتصاد مالی، 14(54)، 135-107.
محمودی­نیا، داود. (1402). نظریه بازی­های مقدماتی؛ کاربرد در اقتصاد و سایر رشته­ها (جلد اول). رفسنجان: انتشارات دانشگاه ولی­عصر­(عج) رفسنجان.
محمودی­نیا، داود، بخشی دستجردی، رسول، و جعفری، سمیه. (1396). استخراج قاعده بهینه سیاست پولی و مالی در چارچوب نظریه بازی­ها: کاربردی از مدل­های تعادل عمومی پویای تصادفی. فصلنامه نظریه­های کاربردی اقتصاد، 4(4)، 143-174.
محمودی­نیا، داود، دلالی اصفهانی، رحیم، انجوردا، جکوب، و بخشی دستجردی، رسول. (1395). نظریه بازی­ها و نقش آن در تعیین سیاست­های بهینه در تقابل استراتژیک بین سیاست­گذار پولی و مالی (کاربردی از نظریه بازی­های دیفرانسیلی و استاکلبرگ). فصلنامه مطالعات اقتصادی کاربردی، 5(18)، 1-18.
هاشم‌لو، بهاره، حقیقت، جعفر، صادقی، حسین، عاقلی، لطفعلی، و نوبهار، الهام. (1398). تحلیل رفتار متقابل بانک مرکزی و سازمان برنامه و بودجه (مطالعه موردی ایران با استفاده از نظریه بازی‌ها). فصلنامه پژوهش­ها وسیاست­های اقتصادی، ۲۷(۹۲)، 133-175.
Aarle, B. V., Engwerda, J. C., & Plasmans, J. (2002) Monetary and Fiscal Policy Interaction in the EMU: A Dynamic Game Approach. Annals of Operations Research, 109, 229–264
Alesina, A., & Tabellini, G. (1987). Rules and Discretion with No coordinated Monetary and Fiscal Policies. Economic Inquiry, 25(4), 619-630.
Bartolomeo, D.G., Giuli, F., & Manzo, M. (2009). Policy Uncertainty, Symbiosis, and the Optimal Fiscal and Monetary Conservativeness. Empirica, 36, 461–474.
Bartolomeo, G., & Giuli, F. (2011). Fiscal and Monetary Interaction under Monetary Policy Uncertainty. European Journal of Political Economy, 27, 369–37.
Bruin, D. B. (2005). Game Theory in Philosophy. Topoi, 24, 197–208.
Buti, M., Larch, M., & Balboni, F. (2009). Monetary and Fiscal Policy Interactions in the EMU when Cyclical Conditions are Uncertain. Empirica, 36(1), 21-44. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1007/s10663-008
Büyükbaşaran, T., Çebi, C., & Yılmaz, E. (2020). Interaction of Monetary and Fiscal Policies in Turkey. Central Bank Review, Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cbrev.2020.03.001
Chakraborty, L. S., & Harikrishnan, S. (2022). COVID-19 and Fiscal-Monetary Policy Coordination: Empirical Evidence from India. Levy Economics Institute, Working Papers Series, 1002(2022), Retrieved from http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4028927
Cochrane, J. (2009). Understanding Fiscal and Monetary Policy in 2008-2009. Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago. Retrieved from https://www.chicagofed.org/~/media/others/research/research-calendarattachments/seminars-2009/sem-cochrane062609-pdf.pdf
Corley, H. W. (2017). Normative Utility Models for Pareto Scalar Equilibria in n-Person, SemiCooperative Games in Strategic Form. Theoretical Economics Letters, 7, 1667-1686.
Demid, E. (2018). Fiscal and Monetary Policy: Coordination or Conflict? International Economic Journal, 32(4), 547-571. Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.1080/10168737.2018.1534133
Dixit, A., & Lambertini, L. (2003). Symbiosis of Monetary and Fiscal Policies in a Monetary Union. Journal of International Economics, 60(2), 235-247.
Dixit, A., Skeath, S., & Reiley, D. (2015). Games of Strategy (Fourth Ed.). New York: W. W. Norton.
Dwobeng, E., & Corley, H. (2022). Forming Coalitions in Normal-Form Games. Theoretical Economics Letters, 12, 1472-1488.
Engwerda, J. C. (2005). LQ Dynamic Optimization and Differential Games. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons.
Engwerda, J. C., Bas Van Aarle, B., Plasmans, J., & Weeren, A. (2013). Debt Stabilization Games In The Presence Of Risk Premia. Journal of Economic Dynamics & Control, 37, 2525–2546.
Engwerda, J., Mahmoudinia, D., & Dalali Isfahani, R. (2016). Government and Central Bank Interaction under Uncertainty: A Differential Games Approach. Iranian Economic Review, 20(2), 225-259.
Favero, C. A. (2004). Comments on Fiscal and Monetary Policy Interactions: Empirical Evidence on Optimal Policy Using a Structural New-Keynesian Model. Journal of Macroeconomics, 26, 281–285.
Hashemlou, B., Haghighat, J., Sadeghi, H., Agheli, L., & Nobahar, E. (2020). Analyzing the Interaction between the Central Bank and the Plan and Budget Organization (A Case Study of Iran Using Game Theory). Quarterly Journal of Economic Research and Policies, 27(92), 133-175. (In Persian).
Kirsanova, T., Stehn, S. J., & Vines, D. (2005). The Interactions between Fiscal Policy and Monetary Policy. Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 21(4), 532–564.
Kuttner, K. N. (2002). The Monetary-Fiscal Policy Mix: Perspectives from the U.S. The conference on The Monetary Policy Mix in the Environment of Structural Changes, sponsored by the National Bank of Poland, October 24–25, 2002.
Lambertini, L., & Rovelli, R.  (2005). Monetary and Fiscal Policy Coordination and Macroeconomic Stabilization. A Theoretical Analysis. Dipartimento di Scienze Economiche Universit`a di Bologna, Retrieved from https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/Delivery.cfm?abstractid=380322
Lane, P. (2004). Monetary-fiscal Interactions in an Uncertain World: Lessons for European Policymakers (Doctoral Dissertation). Trinity College, Dublin.
Leitemo, K. (2004). A Game between the Fiscal and the Monetary Authorities under Inflation Targeting. European Journal of Political Economy, 20, 709–724
Mahmoudinia, D. (2023). Introductory Game Theory (Application in Economics and Other Fields), 1. Rafsanjan: Vali-e- Asr University of Rafsanjan (In Persian).
Mahmoudinia, D., & Zeid Abadi, A. (2021). The Interaction of the Government and Central Bank Behavior in a Leader-Follower Game despite of the Risk Premium. Financial Economics, 15(54), 107-135 (In Persian).
Mahmoudinia, D., Bakhshi Dastjerdi, R., & Jafari, S. (2018). Extraction of Optimal Fiscal and Monetary Policy Rules in Framework of Game Theory: Application of Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium Model. Quarterly Journal of Applied Theories of Economics, 4(15), 143-174 (In Persian).
Mahmoudinia, D., Dallali Esfahani, R., Engwerda, J., & Bakhshi Dastjerdi, R. (2016). Game Theory and Its Role in Determining Optimal Policies and Strategic Interaction between Fiscal and Monetary Policymakers (Application of Differential Game Theory and Stackelberg Games). Applied Economics Studies Iran, 5(18), 1-34 (In Persian).
Mohtashami, M., Ehsani, M. A., & Feizi, M. (2020). A Welfare Analysis of Interactions between Government and Central Bank: The Policy Games Approach. Journal of Economics and Modelling, 11(43), 1-31 (In Persian).
Ng’Ang’A, W, I., Chevallier, J., Wagura Ndiritu, S. (2019). Investigating Fiscal, Monetary Policies Coordination and Public Debt in Kenya: Evidence from Regime-Switching and Self-Exciting Threshold Autoregressive Models. Economics Discussion Papers, 2019-40, 1-37.
Sargent, T. J., & Wallace, N. (1981). Some Unpleasant Monetarist Arithmetic. Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Quarterly Review, 5(3), 1-17.
Saulo, H., Rêgo, L. C., & Divino, J. A. (2013). Fiscal and Monetary Policy Interactions: A Game Theory Approach. Ann Oper Res, 206, 341–366.
Šehović, D. (2013).  General Aspects of Monetary and Fiscal Policy Coordination. Journal of Central Banking Theory and Practice, 3, 5-27
Semmler, W., & Haider, A. (2018). Cooperative Monetary and Fiscal Policies in the Euro Area. Southern Economic Journal, 85(1), 217–234.
Stawska, J., Malaczewski, M., Malaczewska, P., & Stawasz-Grabowska, E. (2023). The Central Bank or the Government – Who Really Dictates the Terms of the Policy-Mix Cooperation in Economies with an Independent Monetary Policy. Economic Research-Ekonomska Istraživanja, 36(2), 2142258.
Tavakolian, H., & Taherpoor, J. (2022).  Fiscal and Monetary Policy Interaction in Iran: A TVP-VARMA Model. Iranian Economic Review, 26(3), 637-665.
Tavakolian, H., Taherpour, J., & Mohsenpour, F. (2019). Monetary and Fiscal Policy Interaction in Iran: A Dynamic Stochastic General Equilibrium Approach. Quarterly Journal of Economic Research and Policies, 27(90), 195-241 (In Persian).
Tijs, S. (2003). Introduction to Game Theory. Delhi: Hindustan Book Agency
Togo, E. (2007). Coordinating Public Debt Management with Fiscal and Monetary Policies: An Analytical Framework. Policy Research Working Paper, 4369, http://treasury.worldbank.org/bdm/pdf/3_CoordinatingPDMwithFiscalandMonetaryPolicies_Togo.pdf
Von Neumann, J., & Morgenstern, O. (1944). Theory of Games and Economic Behavior. New Jersey: Princeton University Press.
Woroniecka – Leciejewicz, I. (2015). Equilibrium Strategies in Fiscal-Monetary Game. A Simulation Analysis Operations Research and Decisions, 2, Retrieved from https://doi.org/10.5277/ord150205
Yeung, D. W. K., & Petrosyan, L. A. (2005). Subgame Consistent Solutions for a Class of Cooperative Stochastic Differential Games with Nontransferable Payoffs. Journal of Optimization Theory and Applications, 124, 701–724. 
Journal of Economic Research (Tahghighat- E- Eghtesadi)
Volume 59, Issue 4
March 2025
Pages 677-714

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 25 March 2024
  • Revise Date: 12 March 2025
  • Accept Date: 04 May 2025

Share

How to cite

Statistics